"....The staff is sick and tired of the impunity extended by the office of the Secretary-General to senior managers for their failings especially in situations where it has led to death and disability....."
- UN Staff Union
Tuesday, August 9, 2011
'The Whistleblower' Film Debuts, But Has Anything Changed for United Nations Whistleblowers?
The Whistleblower, which details the true story of the United Nations’ complicity in the sex-trafficking industry in Bosnia, debuts Friday in select theaters, with widespread distribution to follow. The movie, starring Oscar-winner Rachel Weisz as real-life truth-teller Kathryn Bolkovac,chronicles Bolkovac’s attempts to blow the whistle in the late 1990s and early 2000s while working with the UN International Police Force.
As GAP’s International Program Officer, one of my job duties is to monitor whistleblower rights and cases at the United Nations. I'm obviously eager to see the film, and GAP will put out a review of it in the coming weeks. If the movie sticks to the known facts about the actual events, it may raise much-needed awareness of whistleblower problems at the United Nations. As a Human Rights Watch official stated about Bolkovac's tale:
“Women and girls trafficked into Bosnia and Herzegovina's brothels endured debt bondage, rape, and beatings. International police and peacekeeping forces should have protected these victims. Instead, some committed trafficking crimes. Kathy Bolkovac bravely blew the whistle on them. She paid a high price in her career, but had the integrity to take a stand against grave human rights abuses.”
Focusing on Bolkovac's case, it seems the perfect time to ask: What has changed? If a UN whistleblower were to come forward today – a decade later – with similar allegations to those made by Bolkovac, would s/he also “pay a high price” for making disclosures?
Unfortunately, the answer appears to be yes.
To the credit of the United Nations, the organization has taken several actions in the past decade to better protect whistleblowers. Advances include:
The passage of an improved whistleblower policy: In 2005, in the wake of the Oil-for-Food scandal and disclosures by several former UN employees about sexual abuse by UN forces, then Secretary-General Kofi Annan issued a whistleblower protection policy that was developed after months of consultation with GAP and other experts in whistleblower law. The policy established an independent Ethics Office, with staff responsible for receiving appeals for protection from whistleblowers.
The reform of the United Nations justice system: In 2006, a panel of independent international jurists found that the UN internal justice system failed to meet “many basic standards of due process established in international human rights instruments” and could not adequately resolve conflict within the Organization. This panel observed that although two-thirds of UN staff members served in field operations, the system of justice in the field was particularly weak. Because the UN enjoys sovereign immunity, staff and troops therefore had no access to any impartial judicial mechanism to contest violations of their own rights.
In July 2009, the United Nations launched a new, decentralized internal justice system based in part on the panel’s proposal. The new system consists of the United Nations Dispute Tribunal (UNDT), the first instance of the two-tier justice system, and the UN Appeals Tribunal (UNAT), which any current or former staff member can appeal a UNDT decision to. Although the system’s initial decisions appear to be favorable to whistleblowers, the system remains severely underfunded, to the point that UNAT judges routinely preface the release of their judgments with pleas to the Secretary-General for additional funding. Also, on several occasions, Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon has failed to respect the authority of the new Tribunals.
In its first year of operation, nearly 20 percent of the cases that were filed with UNDT originated in peacekeeping missions. UNDT will soon release a decision involving one of the heroes portrayed in The Whistleblower, Madeline Rees (who is played by Vanessa Redgrave). Rees maintains that she was fired for the actions depicted in the movie and for helping to blow the whistle on the UN’s “collusion in the rendition of six Algerian nationals to Guantanamo Bay.”
These two reforms were a step in the right direction, but were significantly weakened by subsequent actions taken by Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon. Moreover, despite these reforms, significant obstacles remain for UN whistleblowers, including:
Fragmented whistleblower policies and processes: Because of a bulletin issued by Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon in 2007, at least seven UN funds, programmes and specialized agencies now have their own, piecemeal whistleblower policies, many of which are weaker than the UN Secretariat policy. This bulletin authorized the replacement of one overarching Ethics Office (charged with reviewing retaliation complaints and safeguarding the interests of whistleblowers) with a proliferation of ad hoc ethics offices that lack the autonomy needed to be effective and impartial. Some of these Offices have no dedicated funding and others are severely understaffed. The Secretary-General’s bulletin ultimately complicated and confused the whistleblower protection system in the UN, creating an entirely new level of bureaucratic dispute, delay, cost and inefficiency for those who report corruption in UN operations and suffer retaliation as a result.
The record of the UN Secretariat Ethics Office: According to annual Ethics Office reports to the Secretary-General, from August 1, 2007 to July 31, 2010, a prima facie case of retaliation was found by the UN Secretariat Ethics Office in only 1.5% of the whistleblower cases that it received (2 out of 134). In other words, there appeared to be, on first examination, evidence that whistleblowing was a contributing factor in causing the alleged retaliation or threat of retaliation in only two cases. These two cases were referred for investigation, but the whistleblower was not necessarily vindicated. Thus, the Office has failed to protect at least 98.5% of UN whistleblowers who have approached it for help.
The record of the Office of Internal Oversight Services Investigations Division (OIOS/ID): This office is charged with investigating whistleblower retaliation cases after the Ethics Office has ruled that a prima facie case of retaliation exists. However, OIOS/ID has refused to investigate some whistleblower retaliation cases.
Incidentally, OIOS/ID also investigates allegations of sexual exploitation & abuse and fraud. Although GAP has been critical of OIOS/ID’s handling of these two issues in the past, there are silver linings to this cloud. First, a new director has finally been named to head OIOS/ID, after the position sat vacant for more than three years. Second, the latest report on Peacekeeping Operations from OIOS (A/65/271/part II) suggests that it has improved its record of investigating sexual exploitation and abuse cases.
According to the report, OIOS/ID investigated more than 30 cases of sexual exploitation and abuse in Peacekeeping Operations in 2010 and substantiated many of these allegations. For example, at the UN Mission in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), OIOS/ID:
Investigated reports of sexual abuse of minors, substantiating that at least five peacekeepers had sexually abused young girls and, in at least three cases, had taken photographs of themselves posing with the victims, which included one set of photographs that were sexually explicit. The Department of Field Support provided the investigation results to the concerned troop-contributing country on 2 June 2010. Three of the subjected peacekeepers were reported to have been jailed (for two months and seven days), incurred demotions in rank and were prohibited from future deployment to peacekeeping missions; and one was cleared. The relevant troop-contributing country’s response in respect of the fifth peacekeeper is still pending.
OIOS also investigated the sexual exploitation of a local DRC woman by a United Nations Police Officer and a United Nations Security Officer. OIOS concluded “that the officers had engaged in sexual acts with the woman while driving a United Nations vehicle.” But it is unclear whether or not the responsible parties were ever disciplined, as OIOS’ account only says that:
“the Department of Field Support provided the investigation report concerning the Police Officer to the concerned police-contributing country on 27 April 2010, while the investigation report concerning the Security Officer was referred to the United Nations Office for Project Services for its consideration and appropriate action.”
The UN has an obligation to ensure that it fully investigates sexual exploitation and abuse reports and protects whistleblowers that raise these issues. While it appears from the reports above that some progress has been made on the former issue, much remains to be done on the latter.
Rumor has it that top UN officials are concerned that The Whistleblower could harm the UN’s reputation, and they have reason to be concerned -- not only because of the events depicted in the movie, but also because the Organization has failed to take sufficient corrective measures to ensure that such abuses will be detected and addressed in peacekeeping operations today. Until the UN can show that it has a credible record of protecting whistleblowers, employees who are aware of sexual exploitation, or other human rights abuses, in peacekeeping operations are likely to remain silent. As a result, opportunities to curb atrocities similar to those depicted in The Whistleblower will continue to be lost.
Shelley Walden is the International Officer at the Government Accountability Project, the nation's leadingwhistleblower protection and advocacy organization.
637 UNDP Staffers are Millionaires, and another 1041 UNDP staffers have enough salary (income) to justify million dollar homes in New York (or tri-state area NY/NJ/CT).
UN/UNDP's budgets are untransparent !
U.N. budget is “utterly opaque, untransparent and completely in the shadow” and would benefit from being consolidated and audited from the outside. MMB from NyTimes
JOSE RAMOS HORTA - PRESIDENT OF EAST TIMOR
‘‘You know how many layers of bureaucracy there are when the European Union wants to help East Timor? Well, they don’t provide the funds to us, the funds allocated are managed by world bank. And the world bank has its own layers of bureaucracy. And they charge for that. The project is then managed by UNDP. But UNDP is only good at doing studies, they don’t execute projects.’‘
Boutros Boutros-Ghali on UN:
"perhaps half of the UN work force does nothing useful"
Can Helen Clark be trusted on Climate Change ?
President Obama's answer to Helen Clark's appeal for US to do more on climate change was : "I think the American people right now have been so focused, and will continue to be focused, on our economy and jobs and growth that ... if the message is somehow, we're going to ignore jobs and growth simply to address climate change, I don't think anybody's gonna go for that," he said. "I won't go for that."
In 2011 Rami Makhlouf - a trusted development partner of UNDP in Syria
In 2008 U.S. Treasury designation: Rami Makhluf Designated for Benefiting from Syrian Corruption (Click on photo to see US Treasury page)
"Screwed" How Foreign Countries Are Ripping America Off
A full chapter (7) dedicated to UNDP and UN Secretariat. But it today at Amazon.com (click above picture)
Asma al-Assad is UNDP's champion of reform in Syria
UNDP's special relations with dictators and terror is well documented. Yet, they continue to operate covered by UN Immunity. Click on immage for story.
Aicha Gaddafi You are Fired !
UNDP continues to be in bed with other dictators. Will clean it one at a time.
Where is NETAID money David Morrison?
UNDP Transparency Censored
UNDP's moto is: - eliminate the uncomfortable, frighten those who disagree, "educate" the perplexed..
UNDP Chief Finance Officer
The UNDP is a secretive organization and so far has kept in the dark every information related to its Chief Finance Officer and Deputy Assistant Administrator, Mr. Darshak Shah. Click on the picture for more on Finance Office of UNDP.
UNDP Belarus - best breast corner
Should tax-payers dollars be used to photograph beautiful breasts - even when making a valid point?
Uncle Helen turning UNDP into a cove of corrupt NZ labour politicians
CLICK ON PICTURE TO SEE Chris Carter's latest Credit Card scandal - can he work at UNDP after that? It seems YES he is full tested!!
Helen Clark says: "No more cars"
Thinking about buying a new car this year? Why, you evil Westerner! You don’t need that. You are demanding your new car off the sweat, toil, and exploitation of the world’s poorest people in developing countries.
Eveline Herfkens belongs to Jail - she should return imemdiately Dutch Taxpayers money.
if anyone else would have done what Eveline Herfkens did, would have long been in jail. We denounce this impunity and demand justice.
Andrew Mitchell - says Helen Clark is up to no good!
1. UNDP’s partnership with the World Bank needs to be more effective, particularly in fragile and crisis-affected countries. 2. UNDP’s near universal mandate means its technical resources are spread very thinly. The Board does not provide strategic direction. HR management is weak. It has a weak results chain. 3. There is limited evidence of active senior management consideration of cost control. Country evidence points to mixed progress on demonstrating cost-efficiency. 4. The Executive Board is politicised and there is a lack of consensus on the key areas for reform. It is not clear that current plans for change will deliver the required depth and breadth of reform. 5. Evidence gathered at country level was highly critical of UNDP’s ability to deliver results. Its delivery can be undermined by staffing issues and bureaucratic processes. 6. Its performance in fragile states is mixed. It has reasonable training and a range of guidance and analytical tools but struggles to fill posts. 7. There is no evidence that the Climate Strategy was directly guiding resource allocation decisions
Mark Malloch Brown outraged over Aicha Gaddafi
“I hope she's not a UNDP Ambassador,” ...“I don't think it's UNDP. I was surprised when I saw that... she was an Ambassador to any part of the UN system.”
Travel Palestine - Rediscover Your Senses
Get ready to a sensual feast of ...sounds...scents of The Land of حماس Ḥamās Documentary sponsored by UNDP Funds (click on picture for video)
Helen Clark on UNDP's own corruption (Can she be trusted?)
“When funds intended for life-saving treatment and prevention are stolen, that theft is tantamount to murder.” CLICK ON PICTURE FOR MORE
Scandal in Rwanda with Human Development Report
Aurelien Agbenonci, UNDP's RR in Kigali accuses Khalid Malik of making up data without UNDP Rwanda's knowledge. Rwanda Government is unhappy !!!
H.E. Dirk Niebel - German Development Minister
"I take the accusations made in the media concerning corruption and breach of fiduciary duty at the Global Fund very seriously and I am sure that the Fund will clarify the matter without delay. Germany is one of the biggest donors to the Global Fund. I have therefore seen to it that a special review will be held. I have frozen all further disbursements to the Fund until matters have been fully clarified, and I will ask a representative of the Fund to come to the BMZ to discuss the matter."
US Amb. Joseph Torsella blows the whistle on UN budgets
U.N. Secretariat’s proposed $5.2 “regular” budget for 2012-2013, was “simply loosening our belt a little less than we originally planned.”
The U.N. Exposed
How the United Nations Sabotages America's Security and Fails the World (Click in picture to purchase the book)
Share now information about illegal dealings at United Nations
If you are in possession of UNDP or any other United Nations Agency' contracts, correspondence, financial records or databases, which you believe detail wrongdoing such as fraud, mismanagement and abuse of authority, and you have failed to have UN's internal control, oversight and justice systems respond and/or react to your claims, you can send them to UNDP-WATCH and we will make them public keeping your identity anonymous and confidential.
Send an email to: firstname.lastname@example.org
Helen Clark is watching you!
Gaddafi aint got nothing on UNDP - Click on the picture for more!
Malakia: A Turk advises Greece on Economy
Kemal Dervis (Turkish) and George Papandreou (Greek) share many late-night phone calls together (Click on picture to read story)
Where does Ban stand on Libya?
C'est vraiment ce que tu veux pour ta carriere?
United Nations Dispute Tribunal finds Ethics Office decisions Appealable
Because UNDT is the first level of the UN’s two-tiered justice system, there is a possibility that this decision may be appealed. Hopefully, the Secretary-General will not be “absurd” enough to do so. Click above to go to GAP page.
Andrew Mitchell Demands Transparency from United Nations
And I promise you as well that in future, when it comes to international development, we will want to see hard evidence of the impact your money makes. Not just dense and impenetrable budget lines but clear evidence of real effect
YOUR TAX DOLLARS AT UNITED NATIONS
Ban Ki Moon supports Ethics Decision on UNDP North Korea
Question: He recommends strongly that UNDP pays 14 months back pay to the whistleblower. Does the Secretary-General stand behind that recommendation? Should UNDP in fact pay that money, or are they free to rebuff that recommendation? Spokesperson: We will see what is going to happen. The Secretary-General of course is behind Mr. Benson on his report. There is no doubt about it. What UNDP will do, we will be seeing this; how they will implement that report.
UNDP Watch is a grouping of United Nations Staff committed to openness. We believe that everyone has the right to access information held by United Nations.
Despite a stated commitment to openness, UNDP remain a highly secretive agency.
Although a wealth of information is available on some UNDP websites, its Executive Board operate behind closed doors, much important programme and administrative information is never made available and, as a rule, information that is disclosed is provided only after relevant decisions have effectively been taken.
While UNDP has adopted “internal policies” on information disclosure, they in fact operate on precisely the opposite presumption. For the most part, they list which documents will be disclosed and when, and there is a presumption against the disclosure of all the other information they hold. They do not establish right of access, the lists of documents subject to disclosure is limited, they do not set out clear and narrow grounds for refusing access and they do not provide for independent oversight mechanisms to ensure proper implementation of the policy.
The UNDP WATCH is calling for the complete overhaul of these policies.
"...We believe that without accountability, there is impunity. We ask that you (Secretary General) not be complicit in cover-up of what happened prior to 11 Dec attack. The staff is sick and tired of the impunity extended by the office of the Secretary-General to senior managers for their failings especially in situations where it has led to death and disability."